6.0 MOBILISATION
OF GLOBAL AND DOMESTIC RESOURCE
6.1
Foreign Venture Capital Investors(FVCIs)
6.1.1
At present, offshore investors make investment in VCU either by investing in
domestic venture capital funds by seeking one time approval from FIPB through
FDI route directly. However, this requires FIPB approval for every single
investment. Further, for every investment and disinvestment, RBI approvals
are required in respect of pricing of securities. The Government of India
guidelines provide for one time FIPB approval in the case of venture capital
fund with 100% investment by offshore investors, but in practice, requirement
of taking approval for pricing of securities from RBI remains for every
investment and disinvestment. Foreign investors find the requirements of
taking FIPB/RBI approvals very cumbersome and time consuming.
6.1.2
Most of the offshore investors are incorporated in tax havens particularly
Mauritius to have the benefit of double tax treaty and they do not have an
incidence of tax in India. These investors feel that if making investment in
India is made hassle free and automatic in a transparent manner with proper
tax exemptions, there would be no need for them to adopt Mauritius route and
avoid several operational problems. FVCIs therefore shall be provided tax
exemptions. This provision will put all FVCIs, whether investing through
Mauritius route or not, on the same footing.
6.1.3
Realising the importance of venture capital investments for the development
of industry and business in India, it is necessary that inflow of such
investments are encouraged and facilitated. In case of FIIs there is already
a hassle free and automatic route for investment and repatriation without
specific FIPB/RBI approval for investments and disinvestments. Once registered
with SEBI, FIIs can freely make investments. This has brought positive
investment and the net investment are around US$10 billions. It would
therefore, be desirable that atleast at par with FIIs. FVCIs are allowed the
facility of registration with SEBI and once registered they should have the
same facility of hassle free investments without any requirement of approvals
from FIPB/RBI. This would also provide authentic data and disclosures as
regards their commitments and investments in VCU in India. Presently, as per
Annexure III of the Industrial Policy 1991, there are already several sectors
which are eligible for the investment under automatic approval route varying
from 50% to 100% of the paid up capital of the companies. In case of NRIs and
OCBs this limit is 100%. Keeping this in view and venture capital being a
thrust area for attracting risk finance for development of business and
industry, 100% inflow of funds of the foreign venture capital investors
should be allowed through automatic approval route without requiring either
FIPB/RBI approval once registered with SEBI. Appropriate regulatory
requirements in respect of FVCIs could be incorporated under SEBI venture
capital funds regulations. Alternatively, FVCIs should be allowed to invest within
overall ceiling of 50% of the paid up capital of the investee company under
automatic route. However, the ceiling of 50% would get substituted by higher
ceilings of 51%, 74% and 100% in respect of the sectors as provided in
annexure III of the Statement of Industrial Policy and would get decreased
accordingly wherever Government of India has prescribed lower ceiling as in
the case of insurance, banking sector etc. This proposal is consistent with
the existing policy of Government of India as regards automatic approvals.
6.1.4
The hassle free entry of such FVCIs on the pattern of FIIs is even more
necessary because of the following factors :
- Venture capital is a high
risk area. In out of 10 projects, 8 either fails or yield negligible
returns. It is therefore in the interest of the country that FVCIs bear
such a risk.
- For venture capital
activity, high capitalisation of venture capital companies is essential
to withstand the losses in 80% of the projects. In India, we do not have
such strong companies.
- The FVCIs are also more
experienced in providing the needed managerial expertise and other
supports.
6.1.5
Further, the FVCI bringing in foreign currency should be permitted to retain
the same in foreign exchange either with the Bank in India or outside till it
is actually invested. Further, as permitted in the case of FIIs they may be
permitted to take forward cover to protect against the currency, price
fluctuation risk.
6.1.6
Recommendations
In view
of the above background, following recommendations are proposed :
- SEBI regulations should be
amended to include provisions for registration and regulation of Foreign
Venture Capital Investor(FVCI) on the pattern of FIIs and once
registered, should be extended .the same facility of hassle free
investment and disinvestment without any approval from FIPB/RBI.
- Foreign VC Investor
(FVCI), registered with SEBI would be eligible to make venture capital
investments under automatic route without any ceiling and any
requirement of FIPB or RBI approval or alternatively, in the overall
ceiling of 50% in any sector under automatic route without FIPB/RBI
approval provided the overall ceiling would automatically get
substituted by higher ceiling of 51%,74% and 100% as prescribed under
Annexure III of Statement of Industrial Policy or will get reduced in
accordance with the ceilings for investment prescribed by Government of
India in certain specified sectors like banking, insurance etc.
- The FVCI should be
permitted to park their foreign remittances in foreign exchange in a
bank in India or outside till actually invested in VCUs and they should
also be permitted to obtain forward cover as permitted to FIIs.
- The Government may
consider providing a tax exemption to registered FVCI to attract large
pool of risk capital directly into India.
6.2
Augmenting the Domestic pool of Resources
6.2.1
The present pool of domestic venture capital and commitments made by FVCIs is
around US$ 1.3 billion. This pool has been predominantly contributed by
foreign funds to the extent of 80%. The domestic pool of venture capital is
very limited. The acute need for venture capital in India is for small and
medium industries which could preferably be financed by domestic venture
capital funds, as the foreign funds, seek to invest in relatively larger
enterprises and the return expectations are also high. The main sources of
contribution for domestic venture capital funds are from financial
institutions, banks, high networth individuals, etc. The venture capital
activity needs to be deep rooted to promote a small and medium scale
industries promoted by professionally qualified entrepreneurs in hi-tech,
research oriented sectors. It is therefore necessary to augment the pool of
resources for domestic venture capital funds.
6.2.2
The investment horizon of a venture capital fund is for a longer duration
ranging from five to ten years and the funds are contributed mainly by the
institutional investors and high networth individuals. Typically, the
institutional investors include Banks, financial institutions, Insurance
Companies, Pension Funds, Private Trusts, Endowments and angel investors
which in case of India are yet not active into venture capital industry. The
expected role of banks, mutual funds and insurance companies in promotion of
venture capital activity in India is discussed hereunder :
6.2.3 Banks: RBI
had recently allowed banks to invest in Venture Capital funds with a
provision that this investment could be treated as priority sector lending.
In order to encourage the banks to provide venture capital to start up
industries, the RBI should treat venture financing by banks under the
priority sectors lending to small scale industries. The investments made by
Banks in venture Capital Funds/Undertakings directly or through subsidiaries,
should not be counted for the purpose of 5% exposure to the capital market.
Further, Banks should be encouraged to extend line of credit to Venture
Capital Funds.
6.2.4 Mutual
Funds: The Mutual Fund industry is fast becoming a channel for routing
private savings into capital market. Given that an appropriate regulatory
framework for Mutual Funds is in place, it would be desirable that the mutual
funds are permitted to invest upto 10% of their corpus in SEBI registered
Venture Funds. Within this ceiling, individual Mutual Funds may have their
own prudential limits. This would also give the opportunity to retail
investors to participate in high growth enterprises through the institutional
mechanism of mutual funds. Further, Mutual Funds can set up a dedicated fund
for investment in VCF / VCU.
6.2.5 Insurance
Companies: Insurance companies typically accumulate large pools of
capital which is available for investment on a long-term horizon. If such
funds are deployed in venture capital industry, these may not only generate
good return to the insurance company, at the same time, would provide
significant resources to the venture capital industry. Insurance companies
may be permitted to invest in SEBI registered Venture capital Funds within
certain ceilings.
6.2.6
It is seen in many developed and developing countries that the entry of
institutional players not only boosted resource mobilisation for venture
capital activity but also over a period of time, these institutional
investors become expert assessors of the investment activities of Funds and
provides appropriate business guidance, as happened in USA. Thus, these
investors not only provide large resources for venture capital activity, but
also help in developing appropriate system for monitoring the investment by
VCF.
6.2.7
RECOMMENDATION
(a) In the light of the above
it is recommended that the mutual fund, banks and insurance companies should
be permitted to invest in SEBI registered venture capital funds.
|